Welcome to the NOSA blog

The true cost of construction accidents

Posted by NOSA on May 15, 2017 11:40:00 AM
NOSA

ConstructionAccidents.jpg

Construction, and the costs of construction accidents, is an area of major concern to employers. Many people do not realise how much accidents really cost, because a lot of the expense isn’t obvious. Attention to accident prevention can and will improve a company's overall success.

 

Where does the money come from to pay for accidents?

Some believe that organisations have money set aside to pay for accident costs. However, employers know that the money must come from profits.

A series of costly accidents can reduce profits radically. Accidents have obvious, direct costs, such as:

  • medical
  • hospital and rehabilitation expenses
  • workers’ compensation payments, and
  • higher insurance premiums or even loss of insurability.

 

But, accidents also have less obvious, indirect costs that are usually uninsured. These include the various disruptions to normal work procedures, such as when employees stop to help the injured employee or even a drop in production that causes inconsistencies with delivery. If profits are not sufficient to cover costs, your company may be forced to defer the procurement of new equipment and facilities.


Insurance isn’t always the answer


People often try to minimise the costs of accidents by saying that they are covered by insurance. Insurance, however, covers only a portion of the total accident cost. Moreover, as accident losses increase, so will your company's insurance premiums. It is clear that directly and indirectly, accidents reduce profitability.

 

You can compare your accident’s total cost to an iceberg

In other words, there is a certain amount of ice (i.e. costs) below the sea depths that you’re unaware of, unless you check for them – or until you crash into them.

 

Examples of hidden costs

  • Production loss/worker distraction
  • Training costs/replacement worker
  • Loss of skill/efficiency – slowed production
  • Paperwork
  • Administrative time
  • Loss of morale
  • Legal issues
  • Medical expenses
  • Wages
  • Equipment
  • Workers’ compensation

 

By closely examining a serious accident that has occurred, you’ll gain a better understanding of what makes up the total cost.

 

Example

Your employee falls from a scaffold that does not have adequate hand rails and is seriously injured. Most workers on site stop working. Some rush to give first aid to the injured person, while others call for help. When help arrives for the injured employee, your employees don’t immediately return to work. Perhaps they are continuing to help or are remaining merely to watch. In this situation, all idle work time is included as part of the total accident costs.

 

What to do next

As soon as the injured person receives proper medical treatment, your next job is to investigate the accident.

 

Remember: You must include all the time you and any other staff spend on investigating and reporting on the accident, as well as the wages you pay to witnesses in the costs.

 

If the injured person misses work for only a short time, you may be able to make up for the production loss by having the rest of the shift work overtime. You will also include the overtime wages you pay in your total accident costs. If the injured employee is gone for months, you may have to hire and train a replacement worker, and they may not be as efficient as your previous employee. If equipment is damaged in the accident and the job must be performed with less effective equipment, your output will drop further. All this reduced efficiency represents another indirect cost.

A good rule of thumb

The indirect costs of accidents are usually greater than the direct costs. For a conservative estimate, you can calculate them on a 1 to 3 ratio. So for every one unit of currency in direct accident costs, there are three units of currency in indirect costs. Some studies indicate the hidden costs can be four to 10 times the insured costs. And for construction, studies have shown that it is SIX times the insured cost.

 

14 indirect costs you need to consider

  1. Time lost from work by injured employee(s)
  2. Loss in earning power
  3. Economic loss to injured worker’s family
  4. Lost time by fellow employees
  5. Loss of efficiency due to break-up of team
  6. Lost time by supervision
  7. Cost of training a new worker
  8. Damage to tools and equipment
  9. Replacement of time damaged equipment
  10. Spoiled work
  11. Loss of production
  12. Spoilage – fire, water, chemical, explosives, etc.
  13. Failure to fill orders
  14. Overhead costs (while work is disrupted)

 

It’s not all doom and gloom – there are also five hidden savings to reap

Just as there are many hidden costs due to accidents, there are hidden savings in accident prevention. Every accident you prevent saves direct and indirect accident costs – money that remains in your profits. Benefits of accident prevention efforts include:

  1. Employees will not be injured or killed.
  2. Property and materials will not be destroyed.
  3. Production will flow more smoothly.
  4. You will have more time for the other management duties of your job.
  5. Increased employee security at work.

 

Need a construction checklist? 

Download

 

Sources:  

https://www.wcf.com/hidden-costs-accidents

http://www.masterbuilders.co.za/news/2016/August/the_real_cost_of_an_accident.htm

Topics: Construction, HSE best practice, hse fails

Download the NOSA HSE Glossary

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

Subscribe to OHSEQ updates